Commander may be the most common way to play Magic, but for my card-buying funds, nothing quite like a limited draft. If you roll up to your local game store on a weekend evening or gather with your playgroup, the pinnacle is the sensation of ripping open a selection of booster packs and constructing a 40-card deck for a fast-paced Magic match.
The draft format evens out the field of play (there's no way to purchase an advantage against your opponents to win), and moreover, you leave with a bunch of fresh cards to add to your commander decks. Yet, there’s a escalating issue in draft (and in MTG's other limited play mode, sealed) that’s only intensifying as Wizards of the Coast and its parent company keep on ramp up the Universes Beyond product line. The problem boils down to two key terms: legendary rule.
Understanding the Legendary Problem
MTG’s long and storied past is filled with fantasy and sci-fi creatures, from genre classics like elves, goblins and iconic original races like phyrexians and eldrazi. A significantly narrower subset of those creatures is legendary, which means that instead of standing for an entire swath of creatures, the individual card represents a specific individual in the Magic: The Gathering multiverse.
The classification of being legendary also has a several other implications in Magic. For one thing, legendary creatures are often stronger and rare than their ordinary counterparts, but this has changed in contemporary sets. There’s also the notorious legend rule, which dictates: If two or more legendary permanents with the same name are controlled by the same player, that player chooses one of them, and the rest are put into their owners' graveyards.
That means you cannot control two of the same legendary permanent at the once, or create a copy (unless you have a specific exception). This doesn’t matter much in commander, where constructed decks are restricted to a single copy of each card, but in draft, where there are no such limits, it’s considerably more impactful.
The Crossover Set Phenomenon Amplifies the Problem
Historically, this was not an issue. Traditional expansions employ legendary creatures judiciously, especially when it comes to common and uncommon cards. Yet, with Universes Beyond, this has ceased to be the situation. Last year’s Marvel's Spider-Man set was brimming with them, with a large percentage of the creatures being legendary-designated, encompassing a notable fraction of the common creatures. Magic’s latest crossover expansion, TMNT, follows no different, and it seems likely that other future Universes Beyond sets like Marvel and Star Trek will follow suit.
This creates an obvious dilemma in limited formats where the best strategy is frequently to build a cohesive deck by selecting as multiple of the copies of a card as possible. In a TMNT draft, you might be persuaded to pick up more than one of a powerful turtle since it works brilliantly with itself, but you’ll only be able to play a single copy due to the legend rule.
The Simple Fix
In a public article, the game’s lead designer, tackled this criticism directly. The biggest advantage is more people have the chance to open a pack with a representation of their beloved character,” the post explained.
On one level, this is understandable. Regardless of personal opinion, the aim of Universes Beyond is to incorporate popular franchises into MTG, and commanding the characters from those universes is a central aspect of that experience. Yet, a lot of these franchises also lack a deep bench of unnamed characters to choose from, which is how you wind up with uninspired cards in crossover expansions. There simply aren’t enough non-legendary character options to support a full set of Magic: The Gathering cards.
In the same blog post, it was also mentioned that there have been efforts to “get rid of the drawback (unsuccessfully) for some time.”
Well, it may be time to implement a change and delete the legend rule — not for all of the game, but for limited formats, only. Consider this, limited decks already differ from other constructed formats by letting you include as many duplicates of a card as you draft; other competitive formats limit you to four copies per card. Eliminating the legend rule in this particular context addresses the issue with very few obvious drawbacks (the probability of someone acquiring two copies of an mythic rare legendary card are low).
This one simple adjustment could preserve Magic the draft experience. Admittedly, another option would be to just cancel Universes Beyond completely. That would also resolve the issue, as well. However, in the meantime, abolishing the legendary rule for a select limited environments would be perfectly effective.